Taylor Swift Steps Out for Dinner with Blake Lively and Sophie Turner

Taylor Swift is stepping out with Blake Lively, Sophie Turner and new pal Brittany Mahomes for a girls’ night!

The Grammy winner was photographed arriving with Turner, Lively and her older sister Robyn to the Italian restaurant Emilio’s Ballato on Saturday — the night before the New York Jets take on the Kansas City Chiefs.

Swift, 33, rocked an LBD with a matching handbag and heels while Lively wore a beige crop top and a multicolored striped skirt with a tweed blazer thrown over her shoulders and tan boots. Turner sported a dark red leather jumpsuit with black heeled leather boots.

The group sat in a back room of the restaurant for over four hours, with Brittany, 28, staying till 1 a.m., while Swift left shortly after around 1:30 a.m.

The “Cruel Summer” singer — who spent time with Brittany at rumored new flame Travis Kelce’s post-game party in Kansas City on Sept. 24 — is expected to be in attendance at MetLife Stadium on Sunday.

Brittany is married to Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes, who called Swift “really cool” at a press conference on Wednesday.

Multiple sources recently confirmed to PEOPLE that Turner has been staying in a New York City home owned by Swift amid her divorce from Joe Jonas after the actress was spotted leaving the residence on Thursday.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Swift and Kelce’s rumored romance first made headlines when she was previously seen cheering on the Chiefs from Kelce’s suite alongside the NFL star’s mother Donna Kelce on Sept. 24.

After the Chiefs’ 41-10 win against the Chicago Bears, a video shows Swift and Kelce, also 33, walking out of the building together and driving off in the athelete’s convertible from the 87 & Running’s Kelce Car Jam, a charity event he had participated in earlier that month.

“They’re having fun,” an insider previously shared of the pair, adding that Swift and Kelce had met before she attended the Sept. 24 game.

According to the source, “This was Taylor’s first time meeting his mom and dad, and everyone was enjoying themselves. She was super chill and low-key hanging out with his friends and family.”

The insider also said that Kelce had “rented out a restaurant” for a small after-party with his friends and family, where Swift was among one of the guests.

“They were cute and normal, just hanging out and chatting,” the source said of Swift and Kelce at the post-game celebration. “They’re just hanging out, and there’s no pressure.”